Plato is a renowned philosopher and
stands alone as the fountain of the tradition among Greek Idealists. Three of
Plato’s writings form the focus in understanding his theory of idealism in
relation to art: Ion, Phaedrus, and The Republic. In The Republic, Plato gave the theory of Ideal State
which is further supported by other ideas and theories.
Plato also talked about Poets and wanted to banish them from hisIdeal State .
To supplement his ambition of banishing Poets he has defined different grounds
long with the Theory of Imitation.
Plato also talked about Poets and wanted to banish them from his
Plato’s theory
of imitation forms the basis for the rest of his philosophy. This
theory deals with metaphysical questions, concerned with nature of existence,
truth and knowledge. Plato by presenting his theory has refuted the pre-Socratic
concepts and has given novel explanation of all these ideas. To understand the
theory of Imitation, it is necessary to read and understand the dialogues between
Socrates and Glucon written by Plato
in The Republic. The dialogues deal
with the formation of an ideal state where Plato banishes the poets. Everything
in the state is modeled on the basis of philosophic ideas and judged by the
closeness to “real” or “true” (archetypal). As in The Republic, the hierarchy of professionals is based upon their
relative proximity to reality. The complexity of this theory lies in the
concept of reality. According to Plato, imitation is a hurdle which could be
crossed to attain the ideals of knowledge, government or virtue.
“The Republic” begins with Socrates
delightful explanation on the “rejection
of imitative poetry” from The Republic. A discussion on the nature of
imitation follows course considering its various demerits.
The concept of
creation is associated with God or the maker since pre-Socratic times, but the
novelty in Plato’s theory is that he declares that God has created ideas (also
called forms) which are not material. These forms or ideas present the real
difficulty in understanding Plato’s theory because the nature of these ideas
could only be imagined or perceived rather than being experienced by our human
senses. Plato is discrediting human senses and says about ideas and essences.
“…real existence is colorless,
formless and intangible, visible only to the intelligence”
According to Plato, all ideas are
made by God:
“…by the natural process of creation,
He is the author of those and of all other things”
The original Ideas
lie with the God. He is the creator. And the relation of all these ideas to the
real object is the first step of imitation. Thus everything found in this world
is an imitation of a real world. The second level of imitation (called to be
thrice removed from reality) is seen in the work of the imitative tribe. Plato
considers all poets and painters to be a part of this imitative tribe, as they
only copy the visible and tangible objects which are themselves mere imitations
of the archetypes (the original idea). So, the work of poets and painters etc
is in fact imitation of an imitation. Plato considers that an idea of the bed
was crated by God which can not be duplicated.
“God, whether from choice or from
necessity, made one bed
in nature and one only; two or more such ideal beds
neither ever have been nor will be made by God”
Now the answering the question “why poets should be banished from The Republic?” is much easier because Plato has placed them (the poets) in the category of those who occupy lowest level of knowledge. Plot has elaborated the backgrounds for banishing poets from The Republic.
in nature and one only; two or more such ideal beds
neither ever have been nor will be made by God”
Now the answering the question “why poets should be banished from The Republic?” is much easier because Plato has placed them (the poets) in the category of those who occupy lowest level of knowledge. Plot has elaborated the backgrounds for banishing poets from The Republic.
The most important
reason
for banishing poets is Morality. Plato says poets are imitators. They
add nothing to reality. A preacher (or a Priest) conveys God’s idea directly.
They convey God’s orders in form of sermons and hymns. They imitate the real
idea and just one step removed from reality. But the poets, even if they write
about God, still they are copying. Plato says poetry is something immoral
because the poets write about gods and goddesses and show their negative
capabilities. Gods and goddesses are shown angry and furious and fighting with
one another. Plato says God should be
given positive qualities instead of negative ones. They should be praised.
Their kind and soft eye should be highlighted. And secondly, the
poetry
makes the readers emotional which results in their weak and coward
morals. Cowardice is a sin and it leads to immorality. An immoral person can do
nothing for the sake of his nation and country. Plato approves
Only those poems which are written
in favor and in praise of God and that we should not give way to impatience.
Emotional
grounds are also very important. Poetry has a spiritual clash; it
weakens our idea, logic and reason.
“And the better part of the soul is likely to
be that which trusts to measure and calculation?”
Mind is superior part of the soul whereas
body is the baser-part and inferior to mind. Poetry does not help us to see
beyond reality. The poetry removes the self-restraints and creates aesthetic
delights and bodily desires. It waters emotions. As Plato says in The Republic;
“awakens … and nourishes and
strengthens the feelings and impair the reasons.”
The reason represents the better
part of the soul while feelings are considered to be the more evil part of a
soul. Plato says Poetry should provoke reason and logic. There should be link
between ourselves and ideas.
The
third ground is of utility. Poets contribute nothing to society. They
lack the courage and dignity to participate in wars even. They can not train
those who want to participate in war. Singers, musicians and poets can not
defend the territories. They give no benefit to the society. They cannot
deliver knowledge to nation as they themselves do not know. Their work distorts
and corrupts immature minds. The children will never understand what they are
conveying. Plato says,
“And the same object appears
straight when looked at out of the water, and crooked when in the water; and
the concave becomes convex, owing to the illusion about colors to which the
sight is liable…”
If a rod is dipped in a glass of
water, its surface seems twisted. The phenomenon can be defined with the help
of scientific study. But if a man who has no knowledge can be deceived by Art. Art
does not add utility. Moreover it distorts the immature minds. Plato
promotes mathematics, logic and sciences.
At
the end comes intellectual ground for banishing Poets from The Republic. Plato says Art should not
be appreciated as it has nothing logical and reasonable. It has deception and
illusion. Poets were of great significance. They used to write poems in praise
of Kings and Queens . Plato himself was a great
admirer of Homer but he criticized Homer and his poetic works. The time, when
Plato was writing The Republic there
was a great collapse. Education system was very poor. Poetry seems an anecdote
against education and resulted in demoralized children. Poetry is based on
human passion and feelings but people believe that poet is divinely inspired
and during the process of writing his mind is taken by divine spirits. The poet
becomes mentally absent and the thing he writes is a god message. Plato agrees
this believe and argues that, a man (the poet) who is not fully aware and
unconscious is not worthy to be trusted. He is a mad man and not in senses. Let
him write what he wants to. It is not worthy to agree and follow him because he
gives no logic and no reason. He may be left alone to enjoy divine inspiration.
Plot supports those writers who highlight patriotism and praise God.
Plato
seems very successful in proving the reasons why he has banished the poets from
The Republic. He talked about all the
aspects of society and the need of a citizen. He knows the importance and
utility of a single person. He does not need idle or emotional people who
contribute nothing towards society.
Bibliography
- Book X from The Republic by Plato.
- Lecture notes
Further Reading : Symbolism in “The Heart of Darkness” by Joseph Conrad
Thanks for this post.
ReplyDeleteThe King Casino Resort - Hertzaman
ReplyDeleteFind งานออนไลน์ the perfect herzamanindir.com/ place to stay, play, and unwind at septcasino Harrah's Resort Southern California. apr casino Get your points now!